5 Supreme Court docket justices rejected an appeals case from Kansas and Louisiana of their effort to withhold Medicaid cash from Deliberate Parenthood. Consequently, two decrease court docket rulings keep in place that block the states from stripping funds from the ladies’s reproductive well being group. Justice Clarence Thomas, one of many three dissenting judges, accused his colleagues of avoiding the case for political causes.
Supreme Court docket Sides With Deliberate Parenthood In Funding Battle
The Supreme Court docket Monday rebuffed efforts by states to dam funding to Deliberate Parenthood. It left in place two decrease court docket opinions that stated that states violate federal legislation after they terminate Medicaid contracts with Deliberate Parenthood associates who supply preventive look after low earnings girls.It could have taken 4 justices to agree to listen to the problem, and solely three conservative justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch — voted to listen to the case. (de Vogue, 12/10)
Supreme Court docket Declines Key Deliberate Parenthood Case
The result’s that folks can proceed to make use of Medicaid cash for pregnancy-related Deliberate Parenthood companies. Now, this isn’t for abortion-related companies. Federal legislation prohibits folks from utilizing Medicaid cash for abortion. However the court docket not taking on this case implies that most states can’t, for now, successfully prohibit folks from utilizing Medicaid funds for different Deliberate Parenthood companies, like screenings, ultrasounds and counseling. (Montanaro, 12/10)
The Related Press:
Justices Will not Hear States’ Attraction Over Deliberate Parenthood
The court docket’s order mirrored a break up amongst its conservative justices and an accusation from Justice Clarence Thomas that his colleagues appeared to be ducking the case for political causes. New Justice Brett Kavanaugh was among the many justices who opted to not hear the case. (Sherman, 12/10)
Supreme Court docket Provides Victory To Deliberate Parenthood In Medicaid Case
Medicaid sufferers in Kansas and Louisiana, two of the states that took motion towards Deliberate Parenthood, claimed the states violated Medicaid’s requirement that sufferers have to be free to hunt their well being care from any certified and prepared supplier. They sued, and decrease federal courts discovered of their favor, getting into injunctions that ordered these states to carry their bans. In declining to take up the states’ appeals, the Supreme Court docket’s motion on Monday leaves these decrease court docket victories for the Medicaid sufferers in place. (Williams, 12/10)
Defunding Deliberate Parenthood? Supreme Court docket Will not Hear Case
Comparable defunding efforts have been blocked in Arizona and Indiana and are being contested in Ohio and Texas. Solely in Arkansas has a federal court docket allowed the state to disclaim funds. (Wolf, 12/10)
That is a part of the KHN Morning Briefing, a abstract of well being coverage protection from main information organizations. Join an e-mail subscription.